Skip to content

Moments That Popped: No. 12 BYU 31, Kansas 29, triple overtime

Highlights & memorable moments from a wild home finale at The Booth on Saturday afternoon against a CFP contender

9 min read
KU quarterback Isaiah Marshall looks for room to run during the Jayhawks' 31-29 triple-OT loss to No. 12 BYU at The Booth on Saturday afternoon in Lawrence. [Kansas Athletics photo]

For the second week in a row, the Kansas football team put together another spirited attempt at keeping its season alive but watched this one fall short in agonizing fashion in a 31-29, triple-overtime home loss to No. 12 BYU.

Kansas, which fell to 4-7 on the season with the loss, had two cracks to walk off victorious. But a pair of failed 2-point conversions in OT and the defense's inability to close the game out on its side left the Jayhawks suffering through that familiar feeling of what could have been.

KU led 6-3 at halftime as Martin Connington knocked through one of his three field goals on the day as time expired on the first half. But, behind a pair of Isaiah Marshall interceptions, BYU outscored KU 13-0 in the third quarter to take control of the game.

KU rallied with a 10-0 edge in the fourth quarter.

Trailing 16-9 and with BYU driving into KU territory, a monster hit by Blake Herold on a short completion on second down forced a fumble and KU's Trey Brown recovered. Initially called a completion and down by contact on the field, replay review overturned the call and KU took over at its own 41, looking to tie the game.

That game-tying score came six plays later when Isaiah Marshall hit Cam Pickett with a perfect pass on 4th-and-8 with around 4 minutes to play.

Marshall, who had his ups and downs in this one, including leaving the game with an injury briefly, threw a dart to Pickett with a few Cougars bearing down on him on the clutch 4th-down play. That tied the game and brought the KU crowd back into it.

It also helped erase the 10 points that BYU scored off of Marshall interceptions earlier in the game.

KU reached overtime in the first place, tied at 16, when BYU kicker Matthias Dunn, who also booted three field goals through the uprights on Saturday, missed badly from 37 yards out on the final snap of regulation.

That's when the fun started.

Both teams scored touchdowns in the first overtime to move to the second OT tied at 23. BYU then scored first in the second overtime but missed the 2-point try, which is required by NCAA rules starting in the second OT.

KU answered that score when Marshall threw it up to Nahzae Cox in the corner of the end zone on 4th-and-8 to tie the game at 29. Suddenly, Kansas was lining up for one play to win it.

KU wideout Nahzae Cox comes down with a clutch 4th-down catch in the end zone in double-overtime of Saturday's loss to No. 12 BYU. [Kansas Athletics photo]

The opportunity never materialized, though, as Marshall's 2-point pass that followed sailed out of the back of the end zone.

Starting with the third OT, NCAA rules require both teams to take 2-point conversion cracks from just outside of the 2-yard line until the game is decided.

KU went first, but the play was blown up before it even got started, as Marshall was harassed while rolling right and never had a chance to get off a pass. BYU was up next and QB Bear Bachmeier found Jojo Phillips in the back of the end zone for the successful conversion and the win.

Up-and-down they went all afternoon, but, just like that, it was euphoria on the BYU sideline, with the Cougars keeping alive both their Big 12 title and College Football Playoff hopes, and devastation on the KU side, with the Jayhawks' season all but over.

"Just lost for words, really," KU defensive end David Santiago said after the game. "I went and spoke to my family, and I was like, 'I don't know what emotions to feel at this point.'"

The Jayhawks will close out the regular season next Saturday at Oklahoma State. Kickoff time for that one has been set for 5:15 p.m. central time on ESPN2.

Here's a look back and some of Saturday's action.



LIKES

• Zeke the gamer – Say what you will about the Marshall interceptions. (And we will a little bit later in this recap). But you also have to give the kid credit for how he bounced back from both of them and how hard he played to give KU a chance to win what would have been a signature victory on Saturday. Marshall finished 20-of-28 passing for 186 yards and 2 TDs through the air and also ran for 90 yards and a touchdown on 18 carries on the ground. All while playing through pain and injury and all while running a lot more than 90 yards when you factor in the scrambling and eluding of defenders that he did on so many plays to keep the Jayhawks alive and give his offense a chance. He's come a long way since the start of the season and it's a shame that he's down to just one more game in his debut season as a starter. There's no doubt, though, that he should have gained enough experience, good and bad, this season to help fine-tune his game in the offseason and come back even stronger.

• Red zone D – The red zone thing probably could go on the likes and dislikes list, with KU knocking in field goals from 28, 24 and 26 yards — just getting six on one of those would've changed how this game played out — but while the offense was struggling to punch it in on its deep drives, the KU defense was doing its part to keep BYU out of the end zone, as well, forcing the Cougars to settle for 3 on its first scoring drives. BYU was 5-for-6 on the day in the red zone, but the one miss was a big one — that 37-yard field goal at the end of regulation — and, as noted, two of the five successful trips were field goals instead of BYU touchdowns, which helped keep KU in the game.

• Santiago the game wrecker – There's been so much made of Leroy Harris III's monster season, and rightly so. But his partner in crime, Air Force/Michigan State transfer David Santiago, has been equally as impressive most of the way and he really showed up in this one, consistently pressuring BYU QB Bear Bachmeier, batting balls down, recording a sack and even forcing a fumble that was recovered by KU. For the game, Santiago finished with 7 tackles, 4 solo, 2 for loss, 1 sack and the forced fumble. He also was banged up late in the game but managed to play through it to the finish.

• Matt Gill's continued resurgence – You've gotta give the KU punter a TON of credit, man. As a true freshman who was struggling mightily earlier this season, the guy was getting absolutely killllllled by everyone pretty much every week for most of this season. But he has punted very well during the past couple of weeks and looked a lot more comfortable back there. That included in this one, when he pinned BYU at the 3 yard line early in the second quarter on a 38-yard punt on 4th and 7 inside BYU territory. Later in the game, with another 4th-and-medium near midfield, Gill pinned the Cougars at their own 7 with a 43-yard punt.

• No penalties by either team – This was one of the wildest things to happen in a Kansas football game, perhaps in the history of the program. No penalties by either team, all afternoon through four quarters and three overtimes. KU coach Lance Leipold noted after the loss that it was a clean game but added that he had been doing this 40 years and never seen anything like that. In fact, he said he joked with one of the officials by asking him during the game if they even brought their flags with them to the stadium.

Two KU defenders converge on BYU ball carrier LJ Martin along the sideline during Saturday's Kansas loss at The Booth. [Kansas Athletics photo]

DISLIKES

• Missed opportunities – There were too many of these throughout the game and a couple on defense. Santiago said it stings when they don't finish because that's the goal each week and the focus does not change when this unit is on the field late in the game with a chance to win it. They're still dialed in and eager to make winning plays, they just haven't been able to get over the hump. One of the biggest missed chances in this one, though, was definitely that 2-point conversion pass that Marshall threw 10 yards out of the back of the end zone at the end of the second overtime. At that point, the teams were guaranteed to at least head to a third overtime. KU had next to nothing to lose. I know he was trying to make a play, and, given that he has overthrown receivers a lot this season, I doubt the miss was an intentional throw-away or anything like that. But you still have to give someone inbounds a chance to make a play. Convert there, lucky, tipped ball, what have you, and you win. Throwing the ball where no one could catch it guaranteed that you were not going to right there.

• Marshall INTs – He's thrown a few this season and quarterbacks are going to do that. But few of them will hurt quite like the two he threw on Saturday. Both set BYU up in Kansas territory and they led directly to 10 BYU points, turning a 6-6 dogfight into a 2-score BYU lead in the second half. BYU's defense made good plays on both picks, but it definitely looked like the first one was more on Marshall, who stared down his receiver from the snap and had him open along the Kansas sideline but could not fire the ball into Nahzae Cox fast enough before the breaking DB jumped in front and picked it off. Marshall now has tossed 10 interceptions this season, compared to 11 touchdowns.

• Interior run D – BYU wasn't particularly great on the ground in this one, but when they were, it often came directly up the middle. And it was more than just QB Bear Bachmeier running into the back of his line and looking for a way to plow forward throughout the end of the game and overtime. LJ Martin ran 25 times for 127 yards to complement Bachmeier's 59 yards on the ground, and the Cougars, as a team, ran for 208 yards on the day, 55 more than the KU rushing attack produced. It made sense for BYU to hit that spot because it helped neutralize — at least a little — what has been absolutely dominant play by KU's D-Ends throughout much of this season.

WHAT THE?

• Yasin Willis returns – Soooo, ummmm, remember all that talk about KU being down to former DB Khi Coleman-Cummings and midseason addition Chase Belcher at running back? Well, scrap that. Not only was Dylan Edwards back after missing most of last week because of injury, but so, too, was Yasin Willis, who had not played since the Arizona State game in London. That gave KU its top two rushers from the start of the season for this one and made the health of the running back run a lot less of a concern. Willis' return was wildly unexpected and he had not been talked about in weeks. He also did not appear on the Big 12's required injury reports throughout the week. It's worth noting, however, that Lawrence Journal-World reporter Henry Greenstein sent an update on X that cited a Big 12 source saying that KU went through the proper channels with regard to having Willis on and off the list throughout the season.

• Fireworks fly! – I get the excitement and, sure, celebrate and feel good when good things happen. But I found it more than a little funny that KU let the fireworks fly from the top of the scoreboard after Dunn's missed field goal at the end of regulation. It became even wilder to look back on when you saw that KU wound up losing the game. It was a big moment, both in the game and in the season, though, so why not, I guess.


— For tickets to all KU athletic events, visit kuathletics.com

Comments

Latest